ftp.cc.uoc.gr
rfc4707
This is a purely informative rendering of an RFC that includes verified errata. This rendering may not be used as a reference.

The following 'Verified' errata have been incorporated in this document: EID 5813, EID 5815, EID 5816, EID 5821, EID 5822, EID 5823, EID 5826, EID 5827, EID 5831, EID 5834, EID 5836, EID 5841
Network Working Group                                            P. Grau
Request for Comments: 4707                                     V. Heinau
Category: Experimental                                    H. Schlichting
                                                           R. Schuettler
                                               Freie Universitaet Berlin
                                                            October 2006


                  Netnews Administration System (NAS)

Status of This Memo

   This memo defines an Experimental Protocol for the Internet
   community.  It does not specify an Internet standard of any kind.
   Discussion and suggestions for improvement are requested.
   Distribution of this memo is unlimited.

Copyright Notice

   Copyright (C) The Internet Society (2006).

IESG Note

   This RFC is not a candidate for any level of Internet Standard.  The
   IETF disclaims any knowledge of the fitness of this RFC for any
   purpose, and in particular notes that the decision to publish is not
   based on IETF review for such things as security, congestion control
   or inappropriate interaction with deployed protocols.  The RFC Editor
   has chosen to publish this document at its discretion. Readers of
   this document should exercise caution in evaluating its value for
   implementation and deployment.

Abstract

   The Netnews Administration System (NAS) is a framework to simplify
   the administration and usage of network news (also known as Netnews)
   on the Internet.  Data for the administration of newsgroups and
   hierarchies are kept in a distributed hierarchical database and are
   available through a client-server protocol.

   The database is accessible by news servers, news administrators, and
   news readers.  News servers can update their configuration
   automatically; administrators are able to get the data manually.
   News reader programs are able to get certain information from an NAS
   server, automatically or at a user's discretion, which provides
   detailed information about groups and hierarchies to the user.

   NAS is usable in coexistence with the current, established process of
   control messages; an unwanted interference is impossible.
   Furthermore, NAS is able to reflect the somewhat chaotic structure of
   Usenet in a hierarchical database.  NAS can be used without
   modification of existing news relay, news server, or news reader
   software; however, some tasks will be better accomplished with NAS-
   compliant software.

Table of Contents

   1. Introduction ....................................................3
   2. Overview ........................................................4
   3. Protocol Level ..................................................5
   4. Description of Functions ........................................6
   5. Definitions .....................................................7
   6. Specification of the NAS Protocol (TCP) .........................8
      6.1. Responses ..................................................8
           6.1.1. Overview ............................................8
           6.1.2. Response Code Values, Structure, and Meaning ........8
      6.2. Connection Setup ...........................................9
      6.3. Commands ..................................................10
           6.3.1. Structure ..........................................10
           6.3.2. Overview ...........................................10
           6.3.3. Detailed Description ...............................10
                  6.3.3.1. HELP ......................................11
                  6.3.3.2. INFO ......................................12
                  6.3.3.3. DATE ......................................13
                  6.3.3.4. VERS ......................................14
                  6.3.3.5. QUIT ......................................15
                  6.3.3.6. LIST ......................................16
                  6.3.3.7. LSTR ......................................18
                  6.3.3.8. HIER ......................................19
                  6.3.3.9. DATA ......................................21
                  6.3.3.10. GETP .....................................22
                  6.3.3.11. GETA .....................................25
                  6.3.3.12. Unknown Commands and Syntax Errors .......27
           6.3.4. Data Headers .......................................27
      6.4. Status Indicators .........................................41
      6.5. Newsgroup Types ...........................................41
      6.6. Hierarchy Types ...........................................42
      6.7. PGP Keys ..................................................42
   7. Specification of the NAS Protocol (UDP) ........................44
   8. IANA Considerations ............................................44
   9. Security Considerations ........................................44
   10. Response Codes (Overview) .....................................45
   11. Data Headers for DATA and HIER Commands (Overview) ............45

   12. References ....................................................46
      12.1. Normative References .....................................46
      12.2. Informative References ...................................47

1.  Introduction

   An increasing number of newsgroups, hierarchies, and articles has
   made the administration of news servers a complex and time-consuming
   task.  The tools for the administration have remained unchanged for
   ten years and are no longer appropriate.  Many hierarchies are
   inconsistent; many new newsgroups are not created or only with a
   large delay; removed groups keep lurking in the configuration files
   for a long period of time.  There is no administration tool that
   utilizes the power of the Internet, and it is not possible to check
   the consistency of the news server at a given point of time.

   Users find it difficult to get an overview of the newsgroups, the
   charter of a particular one, which language is preferred, or whether
   a group is moderated.  Renaming, the status change from moderated to
   unmoderated or vice versa, and the splitting of a group into several
   others are dynamic processes.  These processes are in common use, but
   it takes a long time until every news server is aware of these
   changes.

   An increasing number of faked control messages has appeared in the
   last few years.  Purposely or accidentally, control messages were
   sent to foreign news servers to create or remove a certain group,
   although this was not approved according to the rules of the
   hierarchy in question.  Due to this fact, automatic creation and
   removal are disabled on many news servers, and several dead groups
   have not been deleted.  It is very difficult for users to determine
   the current status of a group, and in some cases they simply cannot
   tell that the group they are posting to is not an active group but a
   dead or invalid one.

   It is the design goal of Netnews Administration System (NAS) to
   provide an out-of-band system that helps to maintain, propagate, and
   deliver the required information.  There will not be any interference
   with current protocols and standards.  It is not intended to make use
   of control messages or some special Network News Transfer Protocol
   (NNTP) commands.  The advantage of NAS is that it provides more
   information in a more structured format than that of control
   messages.  Not only news server administrators but also Usenet users
   can get more detailed information about newsgroups and hierarchies.

   Due to the fact that a client connects to a server and the server
   asks for authentication, this is a more reasonable procedure for
   transmitting information than that for control messages.

   Furthermore, it is possible to check for changes on a regular basis
   at customized intervals to keep local data up-to-date.

2.  Overview

   NAS is based on a database that contains information about certain
   groups and hierarchies.  This database is structured in a
   hierarchical manner and distributed to various servers, and it is
   able to receive queries at any time.  The service is comparable to
   directory services like DNS, Lightweight Directory Access Protocol
   (LDAP), or Network Information Service (NIS).  The NAS protocol is
   inspired by protocols like NNTP and SMTP.  The port 991 is reserved
   for NAS and registered by the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority
   (IANA) [IANA-PN].

   The organizational structure of NAS is hierarchical; this means that
   a NAS root server collects data from the sub-servers that are
   authoritative for certain hierarchies.  The root server signs the
   data and distributes it authoritatively.  Replication of database
   entries is possible.  The hierarchical structure can consist of
   multiple levels.  Usage of the database is possible for news servers,
   news readers, and special client programs.  The communication is
   based on TCP and UDP.

   Taking the real world into account, there might be some policy
   problems with a single root server.  But it is possible to establish
   a structure like that of the current Usenet system, where some
   hierarchies have a good administration with a well-defined system of
   rules, and where some are not well maintained.  The goal is to get as
   much information as possible under one hat, but there can be no
   "official" force to achieve this.

   During the startup phase, it is quite likely that there will be a
   root server, handling just hierarchies with strict rules and accepted
   authorities (e.g., BIG8, de.*, us.*, bln.*, fr.*, it.*).

   However, it is also imaginable to have some NAS servers providing
   data on, for example, alt.!binaries, some providing data on alt.*,
   and even some providing alt.*  following special policies or sets of
   rules.

   An administrator using NAS will have the choice to use just one root
   server (and all its data) or to use another NAS server for special
   hierarchies.

          ..............   ..............     ...................
          .  NAS server.   .  NAS server.     .  NAS server     .
          .            .   .            .     .  alt.*,         .
          .  alt.*     .   .  Big8      .     .  !alt.binaries.*.
          ..............   ..............     ...................
          .  database  .   .  database  .     .  database       .
          ..............   ..............     ...................
                 ^            ^      ^                  ^
                 `--+      +--'      `------+      +----'
                    |      |                |      |
                 .------------.          .------------.
                 | NAS client |          | NAS client |
                 +------------+          +------------+
                 |  netnews   |          |  netnews   |
                 |  server    |          |  server    |
                 .------------.          .------------.

                 Configuration A         Configuration B

                                 Figure 1

   NAS contains information about newsgroups and complete hierarchies.
   Furthermore, it contains information about the hierarchies'
   inheritable entries and default values for a single newsgroup.

3.  Protocol Level

   It is expected that the real-life use of NAS will change the
   requirements for the Netnews Administration System.  On the one hand,
   the protocol has to be extensible and flexible in order to implement
   improvements; on the other hand, it must ensure compatibility between
   different versions.  A simultaneous migration of all sites using NAS
   to a new protocol version is not likely to happen.  To solve this
   problem, NAS has a protocol level.  This protocol level describes the
   current functionality.  The protocol level, being a number between 1
   and 32767, is negotiated at connection setup.  Enhancements and
   modifications must use a different protocol level than that of their
   predecessors.  (Usually the protocol level is incremented by 1 with
   every new version of the protocol specification.) Every current or
   future implementation MUST be compatible with protocol level 1 in
   order to fall back to this level if communication on a higher level
   fails.

   An implementation of higher protocol levels should be able to emulate
   the behavior of lower levels, even if this implies a loss of
   features.  The negotiation of the protocol level between client and
   server is described in the specification of the command VERS.  If
   there is no agreement on the protocol level, only commands of the

   protocol level 1 MUST be used.  Documents enhancing or modifying the
   NAS standard MUST specify on which level these changes take place and
   how the behavior should be in other protocol levels.

   This document describes protocol level 1.

4.  Description of Functions

   In order to use an NAS server, a connection must be opened by the
   client.  The NAS server can be located in the same domain or
   somewhere else on the Internet.

   The NAS system is hierarchical.  The idea is to have an NAS root
   server like the DNS root servers.  The root server distributes the
   data collected from client NAS servers that are authoritative servers
   for their hierarchy.  The maintenance of the authoritative data is
   possible on any system.  The root server collects the data and makes
   them available to other servers, which can in turn distribute these
   data to other servers.  The administrator has the opportunity to make
   use of either all data or only parts of the database.  NAS servers
   can ask multiple NAS servers for data.  An attached time stamp makes
   it possible to distinguish between new and old data and to avoid
   loops in the propagation.

   To describe the NAS in greater detail, it is necessary to emphasize
   the hierarchical design of the NAS system.  The following figure
   shows the propagation of data along the server hierarchy.

   Authoritative data for a newsgroup or a hierarchy are collected and
   written into a database.  These data are available through a local
   NAS server and are collected from this authoritative server by
   upstream NAS servers.

   There may also be NAS servers that are not authoritative servers;
   these servers merely provide the information they collect from other
   NAS servers to clients such as news servers, administration programs,
   and news readers.

            ............     collects from >
            .  root NAS.-------------------------+
            .  server  .----------------+        |
            ............                |        |
            .  database.                |        |
            ............                |        |
                  ^ v                   |   ..........................
                  | |                   |   .  NAS server            .
                  | |distributes        |   .  authoritative for de.*.
           queries| |                   |   ..........................
                  | |                   |   .        database        .
                  ^ v                   |   ..........................
            ..............              |
            .  NAS server.              `--------+
            ..............                       |
            .  database  .                ...........................
            ..............                .  NAS server             .
              ^  ^  ^                     .  authoritative for bln.*.
              |  |  |  .---------.        ...........................
            q |  |  `--| netnews |        .        database         .
            u |  |     | server  |        ...........................
            e |  |     .---------.
            r |  |
            i |  |  .---------.
            e |  `--| admin   |
            s |     | program |
              |     .---------.
              |
              |  .---------.
              `--| news    |
                 | reader  |
                 .---------.

                                    Figure 2

   Requests to an NAS server originating at a client (as well as at
   another server) are accomplished in several steps: establishing a
   connection, authentication (optional), negotiating a protocol level
   (optional), queries on the database, and termination.

5.  Definitions

   The key words "MUST", "MUST NOT", "REQUIRED", "SHALL", "SHALL NOT",
   "SHOULD", "SHOULD NOT", "RECOMMENDED", "MAY", and "OPTIONAL" in this
   document are to be interpreted as described in [RFC2119].

6.  Specification of the NAS Protocol (TCP)

6.1.  Responses

6.1.1.  Overview

   An answer starts with a response code (a three-digit number),
   optionally followed by white space and a textual message.  Then the
   actual text/data follows.  Text is sent as a series of successive
   lines of textual matter, each terminated with CRLF.  A single line
   containing only a single period ('.') is sent to indicate the end of
   the text (i.e., the server will send a CRLF at the end of the last
   line of text, a period, and another CRLF).

      answer = response-code [answertext] CRLF 
            *(text CRLF)
            "." CRLF
EID 5813 (Verified) is as follows:

Section: 6.1.1

Original Text:

   Answer = response-code [answertext] CRLF
            text CRLF
            "." CRLF

Corrected Text:

   answer = response-code [answertext] CRLF
            *(text CRLF)
            "." CRLF
Notes:
There may be zero, one or more additional lines of text followed by a CRLF.
If the original text contains a period as the first character of the text line, that first period is doubled. Therefore, the client must examine the first character of each line received and, for those beginning with a period, determine either that this is the end of the text or that it should collapse the doubled period to a single one. Example <-- INFO --> 101 Information follows Server: nas.example.org (192.0.2.100) Uptime: 2 weeks, 3 days, 5 hours, 9 minutes Software: NAS 1.0 Client: client.example.org (192.0.2.123) Connection: 9 minutes Highest protocol level supported: 1 Requested protocol level: 1 Protocol level used: 1 . 6.1.2. Response Code Values, Structure, and Meaning The first digit of the response code indicates the message type (i.e., information, success, warning, error, or data): 1xx Information 2xx Request successful 3xx Request successful, data follow 4xx Request accepted, but no operation possible 5xx Request is wrong (syntax error), is not implemented, or leads to an internal error 6xx Request successful, data follow until end mark The second digit specifies the message category: x0x Connection-related stuff x1x Queries, answers, or data x2x Server-server communication x3x Authentication, authorization x8x Non-standard extensions x9x Debugging output The actual response code for a specific command is listed in the description of the commands. Answers of the type 1xx, 2xx, 4xx, and 5xx can have a text after the numerical code. 3xx answers contain one or more parameters with data; the exact format is explained in the description of the commands. An answer to an incorrect request may be longer than one line. 6.2. Connection Setup NAS typically uses port 991, which is reserved by IANA [IANA-PN]. If a connection is set up by the client, the server answers immediately (without a request) with the greeting message, which will start with code 200: --> 200 Welcome! nas.example.org ready . If a connection is refused because the client has no permission to access the server, the answer code is 434. That decision can be made on connection startup based on the client's IP address. When the server is currently out of service, the answer code is 404. Examples: --> 434 You have no permission to retrieve data. Good bye. . --> 404 Maintenance time . After sending a 404 or 434 message, the connection will be closed. 6.3. Commands 6.3.1. Structure A command consists of a command word, sometimes followed by a parameter. Parameters are separated from the command word by white space. Commands used in the NAS protocol are not case sensitive. A command word or parameter may be uppercase, lowercase, or any mixture of upper- and lowercase. The length of a command line is not limited. If the need to limit the length of command lines in real-life implementations arises, answer code 513 (line too long) should be returned. The protocol level described in this document uses command words with a length of exactly four characters each. In examples, octets sent to the NAS server are preceded by "<-- " and those sent by the NAS server by "--> ". The indicator is omitted if the direction of the dialog does not change. 6.3.2. Overview The commands described below are defined using the Augmented Backus- Naur Form (ABNF) defined in [RFC4234]. The definitions for 'ALPHA', 'CRLF', 'DIGIT', 'WSP' and 'VCHAR' are taken from appendix B of [RFC4234] and not repeated here. The following ABNF definitions constitute the set of NAS commands that can be sent from the client to an NAS server. 6.3.3. Detailed Description Some overall definitions follow: text = *(%d1-9 / ; all octets except %d11-12 / ; US-ASCII NUL, CR and LF %d14-255)
EID 5841 (Verified) is as follows:

Section: 6.3.3

Original Text:

   text          = %d1-9 /           ; all octets except
                   %d11-12 /         ; US-ASCII NUL, CR and LF
                   %d14-255

Corrected Text:

   text          = *(%d1-9 /         ; all octets except
                     %d11-12 /       ; US-ASCII NUL, CR and LF
                     %d14-255)
Notes:
Each time the "text" keyword is used in ABNF definitions in this RFC, it means "any number, including none, of octets except NUL, CR and LF" and not one such octet.
answertext = WSP *( ALPHA / DIGIT / "+" / "-" / "/" / "_" / "." / "," / ":" / "=" / "?" / "!" / SP ) utc-time = 14DIGIT ; the date and time of the server in UTC ; YYYYMMDDhhmmss response-code = 3DIGIT ; three digit number Newsgroup names and hierarchy names are defined according to the following ABNF definitions. Since a hierarchy name can be the same as a newsgroup name (e.g., hierarchy bln.announce.fub.* and newsgroup name bln.announce.fub), there is no difference between the two. name = plain-component *("." component) component = plain-component / encoded-word encoded-word = 1*( lowercase / DIGIT / "+" / "-" / "/" / "_" / "=" / "?" ) plain-component = component-start *component-rest component-start = lowercase / DIGIT lowercase = %x61-7A ; letter a-z lowercase component-rest = component-start / "+" / "-" / "_" NOTE: This definition of newsgroup name is in reference to "News Article Format and Transmission" [SON1036]. When the document "News Article Format" [USEFOR] is established as an RFC, its definitions should be integrated into a higher protocol level of NAS. 6.3.3.1. HELP Description This command prints a short help text on a given command. If called without parameters, it will display a complete list of commands. help-cmd = "HELP" [WSP commandname] CRLF commandname = "DATA" / "DATE" / "GETP" / "GETA" / "HELP" / "HIER" / "INFO" / "LIST" / "LSTR" / "QUIT" / "VERS" Possible answers 100: Command overview, command description 410: Indicates that the server is not giving any information help-answer = "410" [answertext] CRLF *(text CRLF) "." CRLF help-answer =/ "100" [answertext] CRLF *(text CRLF) "." CRLF
EID 5815 (Verified) is as follows:

Section: 6.3.3.1

Original Text:

   help-answer =  "410" [answertext] CRLF
                  text CRLF
                  "." CRLF
   help-answer =/ "100" [answertext] CRLF
                  text CRLF
                  "." CRLF

Corrected Text:

   help-answer =  "410" [answertext] CRLF
                  *(text CRLF)
                  "." CRLF
   help-answer =/ "100" [answertext] CRLF
                  *(text CRLF)
                  "." CRLF
Notes:
Per the examples shown, it is clear that zero, one, or more lines of text may be supplied.
Examples <-- HELP --> 100 NAS server nas.example.org - Version 1.0 Supported commands: DATA - data for a newsgroup DATE - show time of server in UTC GETP - get package GETA - get data from an authoritative server HELP - show this help HIER - data for a hierarchy INFO - show info on current connection LIST - list newsgroups or hierarchies LSTR - recursive list newsgroups or hierarchies QUIT - close the connection VERS - show or set current protocol level Contact address nas@example.org . <-- HELP LIST --> 100 LIST LIST - list newsgroups or hierarchies Syntax: LIST hierarchy ... Get a list of newsgroups and sub-hierarchies directly under the parameter hierarchy . <-- HELP NOOP --> 410 unknown command "NOOP" . 6.3.3.2. INFO Description Prints information about the current connection, the server, and the client. info-cmd = "INFO" CRLF Possible answers 101: Normal answer; prints some information about client and server 400: Indicates that the server is not giving any information info-answer = "400" [answertext] CRLF *(text CRLF) "." CRLF info-answer =/ "101" [answertext] CRLF *(text CRLF) "." CRLF
EID 5816 (Verified) is as follows:

Section: 6.3.3.2

Original Text:

   info-answer =  "400" [answertext] CRLF
                  text CRLF
                  "." CRLF
   info-answer =/ "101" [answertext] CRLF
                  text CRLF
                  "." CRLF

Corrected Text:

   info-answer =  "400" [answertext] CRLF
                  *(text CRLF)
                  "." CRLF
   info-answer =/ "101" [answertext] CRLF
                  *(text CRLF)
                  "." CRLF
Notes:
Per the examples shown in the text, it is clear that a response may include zero, one, or many additional lines of text.
Examples <-- INFO --> 101 Information follows Server: nas.example.org (192.0.2.100) Uptime: 2 weeks, 3 days, 5 hours, 9 minutes Software: NAS 1.0 Client: client.example.org (192.0.2.123) Connection: 9 minutes Highest protocol level supported: 1 Requested protocol level: 1 Protocol level used: 1 End . <-- INFO --> 400 No information available. . 6.3.3.3. DATE Description Prints the current time of the server in UTC (Universal Coordinated Time) in the format YYYYMMDDhhmmss, followed by an optional comment. The DATE command is only for informational use and to check the server time. For regular transmission of time over the network, the Network Time Protocol (NTP) [RFC1305] should be used. date-cmd = "DATE" CRLF Possible answers 300: Print the UTC time in specified format; see below 511: Error; print an error message date-answer = "511" [answertext] CRLF text CRLF "." CRLF date-answer =/ "300" [answertext] CRLF utc-time [answertext] CRLF "." CRLF Examples <-- DATE --> 300 19990427135230 UTC . <-- DATE --> 511 Time is unknown . 6.3.3.4. VERS Description The VERS command is used to determine the protocol level to use between client and server. The parameter is a protocol level that the client supports and wants to use. The server will respond with the highest level accepted. This version number MUST not be higher than that requested by the client. Client and server MUST only use commands from the level that the server has confirmed. It is possible, but seldom necessary, to change the protocol level during a session by client request (VERS [protocol level]). When no option is given, the current protocol level will be printed. When no protocol level is negotiated, the protocol level 1 will be used. Commands of a higher level are not allowed without successful negotiation. The protocol level can be followed by an optional comment. vers-cmd = "VERS" [WSP level] CRLF level = 1*5DIGIT ; the valid range is 1 - 32767 Possible answers 202: Returns current protocol level 302: Requested level accepted 402: Requested level too high; falling back to lower level 510: Syntax error vers-answer = "202" [answertext] CRLF level [answertext] CRLF "." CRLF vers-answer =/ "302" [answertext] CRLF level [answertext] WSP level CRLF "." CRLF vers-answer =/ "402" [answertext] CRLF level [answertext] WSP level CRLF "." CRLF vers-answer =/ "510" [answertext] CRLF level [answertext] CRLF "." CRLF Examples <-- VERS --> 202 2 Current protocol level is 2 . <-- VERS 2 --> 302 2 My max protocol level is 10 . <-- VERS 11 --> 402 10 Falling back to level 10 . <-- VERS BAL --> 510 1 Syntax error . 6.3.3.5. QUIT Description Terminates the connection. quit-cmd = "QUIT" CRLF Possible answers 201: Termination of the connection quit-answer = "201" [answertext] CRLF Example <-- QUIT --> 201 Closing connection. Bye. 6.3.3.6. LIST
EID 5821 (Verified) is as follows:

Section: 6.3.3.6

Original Text:

   The data consist of a newsgroup- or hierarchy-name/status indicator
   pair per line.  Name and status indicator must be separated by at
   least one white space.
[...]
   listdata    =  name WSP list-status

Corrected Text:

   The data consist of a newsgroup- or hierarchy-name/status indicator
   pair per line.  Name and status indicator must be separated by at
   least one white space.
[...]
   listdata    =  name 1*WSP list-status
Notes:
Only one white space is allowed in the definition of listdata. I suggest allowing several WSP for consistency with the description.
Same remark for the definition of listdata in Section 6.3.3.7 (LSTR command).
Description To obtain a list of newsgroups and sub-hierarchies in the requested hierarchies, the command LIST is used. The status of the hierarchies is also given. The highest level consists of all top-level hierarchies and is labeled "*". It can be obtained this way, too. The data consist of a newsgroup- or hierarchy-name/status indicator pair per line. Name and status indicator must be separated by at least one white space. The status indicator is a single word (see Section 6.4). The interpretation is not case sensitive. list-cmd = "LIST" ( WSP "*" / 1*(WSP name)) CRLF Possible answers 401: Permission denied 510: Syntax error 610: Normal response with all requested data list-answer = "610" [answertext] CRLF *(listdata CRLF) "." CRLF list-answer =/ "401" [answertext] CRLF *(text CRLF) "." CRLF list-answer =/ "510" [answertext] CRLF *(text CRLF) "." CRLF
EID 5822 (Verified) is as follows:

Section: 6.3.3.6

Original Text:

   list-answer =/ "401" [answertext] CRLF
                  text CRLF
                  "." CRLF
   list-answer =/ "510" [answertext] CRLF
                   text CRLF
                   "." CRLF

Corrected Text:

   list-answer =/ "401" [answertext] CRLF
                  *(text CRLF)
                  "." CRLF
   list-answer =/ "510" [answertext] CRLF
                  *(text CRLF)
                  "." CRLF
Notes:
Zero, one, or more lines of text are allowed.
listdata = name WSP list-status The list-status is the status of a newsgroup or hierarchy according to Section 6.4. list-status = "Complete" / "Incomplete" / "Obsolete" / "Unknown" / "Unmoderated" / "Readonly" / "Moderated" / "Removed" ; list-status is case-insensitive Examples <-- LIST * --> 610 data follow alt Incomplete comp Complete de Incomplete rec Complete sub Obsolete . <-- LIST de --> 610 data follow de.admin Complete de.alt Incomplete de.comm Complete de.comp Complete de.etc Complete de.markt Complete de.newusers Complete de.org Complete de.rec Complete de.sci Complete de.soc Complete de.answers Moderated de.test Unmoderated . <-- LIST foo --> 610 data follow foo Unknown . <-- LIST --> 510 Syntax error missing parameter hierarchy . <-- LIST de --> 401 Something is wrong Permission denied . 6.3.3.7. LSTR Description To obtain a recursive list of newsgroups and sub-hierarchies in the named hierarchy, the command LSTR is used. The status of the hierarchies is also given. The highest level consists of all top- level hierarchies and is labeled "*". It can be obtained this way, too. The use of "*" as a wildcard pattern following the beginning of a hierarchy name is also possible; so a "LSTR de.a*" would return a list of all newsgroups and hierarchies starting with "de.a". lstr-cmd = "LSTR" ( WSP "*" / 1*(WSP name ["*" / ".*"]) ) CRLF Possible answers 401: Permission denied 510: Syntax error 610: Normal answer with all requested data lstr-answer = "610" [answertext] CRLF *(listdata CRLF) "." CRLF lstr-answer =/ "401" [answertext] CRLF *(text CRLF) "." CRLF lstr-answer =/ "510" [answertext] CRLF *(text CRLF) "." CRLF
EID 5823 (Verified) is as follows:

Section: 6.3.3.7

Original Text:

   lstr-answer =/ "401" [answertext] CRLF
                  text CRLF
                  "." CRLF
   lstr-answer =/ "510" [answertext] CRLF
                  text CRLF
                  "." CRLF

Corrected Text:

   lstr-answer =/ "401" [answertext] CRLF
                  *(text CRLF)
                  "." CRLF
   lstr-answer =/ "510" [answertext] CRLF
                  *(text CRLF)
                  "." CRLF
Notes:
Zero, one, or more lines of text are allowed.
listdata = name WSP list-status The list-status is the status of a newsgroup or hierarchy according to Section 6.4. list-status = "Complete" / "Incomplete" / "Obsolete" / "Unknown" / "Unmoderated" / "Readonly" / "Moderated" / "Removed" ; list-status is case-insensitive Example <-- LSTR de.admin --> 610 recursive mode de.admin Complete de.admin.infos Moderated de.admin.lists Moderated de.admin.misc Unmoderated de.admin.net-abuse Complete de.admin.net-abuse.announce Moderated de.admin.net-abuse.mail Unmoderated de.admin.net-abuse.misc Unmoderated de.admin.net-abuse.news Unmoderated de.admin.news Complete de.admin.news.announce Moderated de.admin.news.groups Unmoderated de.admin.news.misc Unmoderated de.admin.news.nocem Unmoderated de.admin.news.regeln Unmoderated . 6.3.3.8. HIER Description The command HIER lists all information available about the hierarchy. With the data header "Name", a new data block for each hierarchy is started. The header "Name" gives the name of the hierarchy. The data headers are described in Section 6.3.4. The default is to transmit all available information. It can be limited to a list of desired headers ("Name" and "Status" are always given). A set of comma-separated headers, as an option to the HIER command, will return the requested header fields. hier-cmd = "HIER" 1*(WSP name) [WSP selection] CRLF selection = *( "," header ) ; Describes the data fields ; that are requested header = ALPHA *( ALPHA / "-" ) ; According to section 6.3.4 Example for selection ,Followup,Description : For all entries list Name, Status, Followup and Description Possible answers 401: Permission denied 510: Syntax error 611: Regular answer with all requested data hier-answer = "611" [answertext] CRLF *(hierdata CRLF) "." CRLF hier-answer =/ "510" [answertext] CRLF *(text CRLF) "." CRLF hier-answer =/ "401" [answertext] CRLF *(text CRLF) "." CRLF hierdata = "Name:" WSP text CRLF "Status:" WSP text CRLF *(header ":" WSP text CRLF) [("Ctl-PGP-Key:" CRLF PGP-answer / "Mod-PGP-Key:" CRLF PGP-answer)] PGP-answer: The exact format is described in Section 6.7. Examples <-- HIER de --> 611 Data coming Name: de Status: Complete Serial: 20020823120306 Description: Internationale deutschsprachige Newsgruppen Netiquette: http://www.kirchwitz.de.example/~amk/dni/netiquette FAQ: http://www.kirchwitz.de.example/~amk/dai/einrichtung Ctl-Send-Adr: moderator@dana.de.example Ctl-Newsgroup: de.admin.news.announce Mod-Wildcard: %s@moderators.dana.de.example Language: DE Charset: ISO-8859-1 Encoding: text/plain Newsgroup-Type: Discussion Hier-Type: Global Comp-Length: 14 Date-Create: 19920106000000 . <-- HIER bln --> 401 Permission denied . <-- HIER --> 510 Syntax error missing parameter hierarchy . 6.3.3.9. DATA Description The DATA command corresponds to the HIER command, as explained in 6.3.3.8, but it is used for information about a newsgroup. A summary of codes can be found in Section 6.3.4. data-cmd = "DATA" 1*(WSP name) [WSP selection] CRLF Possible answers 401: Permission denied 510: Syntax error 612: Regular answer with all requested data data-answer = "612" [answertext] CRLF *(datadata CRLF) "." CRLF data-answer =/ "510" [answertext] CRLF text CRLF "." CRLF data-answer =/ "401" [answertext] CRLF text CRLF "." CRLF datadata = "Name:" WSP text CRLF "Status:" WSP text CRLF *(header ":" WSP text CRLF) [("Ctl-PGP-Key:" CRLF PGP-answer / "Mod-PGP-Key:" CRLF PGP-answer)] Examples <-- DATA de.comp.os.unix.linux.moderated --> 612 data follow Name: de.comp.os.unix.linux.moderated Status: Moderated Serial: 20020823120312 Description: Linux und -Distributionen. <dcoulm-moderators@linux-config.de.example> Charter: http://www.dana.de.example/mod/chartas/de.html Netiquette: http://www.kirchwitz.de.example/~amk/dni/netiquette Netiquette: ftp://ftp.fu-berlin.de.example/doc/usenet/german /Netiquette Mod-Sub-Adr: dcoulm-moderators@linux-config.de.example Mod-Group-Info: http://wpxx02.toxi.uni-wuerzburg.de.example /~dcoulmod/ Newsgroup-Type: Discussion . <-- DATA de.foo --> 612 data follow Name: de.foo Status: Unknown . <-- DATA de --> 401 Permission denied . <-- DATA --> 510 Syntax error missing parameter newsgroup . 6.3.3.10. GETP Description GETP is used for server-server communication. It requests the data for the hierarchy specified by the parameter "name". The format of the data is the same as for the commands "HIER" and "LIST". If "*" is given as hierarchy name, all data the server is offering will be transmitted. The "timestamp" attached to a package consists of the date and time that the package was created. The timestamp for a package is transmitted together with the package data by the server and marks a specific revision for the package data. When a client requests a package with GETP, it transmits the timestamp attached to the package in its database so that the server can check whether the data on the client side is still valid or if it is too old. If the data on the client side is still valid, a 213 answer is sent, so the client knows that its data is OK. If the timestamp is "0", the server is forced to transmit the data. Timestamps set by the server must be increasing and may not be more than 12 hours in the future. The data for a successful request are signed and sent in ASCII armor according to [RFC2440], so a client can check the signature or ignore it. The actual data will be surrounded by the armor start and end sections, according to Section 6.2 of [RFC2440]. getp-cmd = "GETP" WSP username WSP password WSP timestamp WSP ( name / "*" ) CRLF username = *1( VCHAR ) / "0" ; Length of VCHAR >= 1 password = *1( VCHAR ) / "0" ; Length of VCHAR >= 1 timestamp = utc-time / ; date and time of the last retrieval "0" ; force the transmission of data Possible answers 213: Current data at the client side 411: No hierarchy with that name 430: Permission denied 510: Syntax error 613: Hierarchy data getp-answer = "613" [answertext] CRLF pgp-ascii-armor-start ; this is according to [RFC2440] *(getpdata CRLF) pgp-ascii-armor-end ; this is according to [RFC2440] "." CRLF getp-answer =/ "213" [answertext] CRLF text CRLF "." CRLF getp-answer =/ "430" [answertext] CRLF text CRLF "." CRLF getp-answer =/ "411" [answertext] CRLF text CRLF "." CRLF getp-answer =/ "510" [answertext] CRLF text CRLF "." CRLF pgp-ascii-armor-start and the pgp-ascii-armor-end are built according to [RFC2440], Section 6.2., "Forming ASCII Armor". getpdata = "Name:" WSP text CRLF "Status:" WSP text CRLF "Serial:" WSP timestamp CRLF *(header ":" WSP text CRLF) [("Ctl-PGP-Key:" CRLF PGP-answer / "Mod-PGP-Key:" CRLF PGP-answer)] Examples <-- GETP 0 0 0 humanities --> 613 data follow
EID 5826 (Verified) is as follows:

Section: 6.3.3.10

Original Text:

   <-- GETP 0 0 0 humanities
   --> 615 data follow

Corrected Text:

   <-- GETP 0 0 0 humanities
   --> 613 data follow
Notes:
Section 10 and also getp-answer in Section 6.3.3.10 indicates a 613 response code for GETP.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 Name: humanities Status: Complete Serial: 20020821094529 Description: Branches of learning that investigate human constructs and concerns as opposed to natural processes. Netiquette: ftp://rtfm.mit.edu.example/pub/usenet /news.announce.newusers /A_Primer_on_How_to_Work_With_the_Usenet_Community Rules: http://www.uvv.org.example/docs/howto.txt Ctl-Send-Adr: group-admin@isc.org.example Ctl-Newsgroup: news.announce.newgroup Language: EN Charset: US-ASCII Encoding: text/plain Newsgroup-Type: Discussion Hier-Type: Global Comp-Length: 14 Date-Create: 19950417143009 Name: humanities.answers Status: Moderated Serial: 20020821094533 Description: Repository for periodic USENET articles. (Moderated) Mod-Sub-Adr: news-answers@mit.edu.example Mod-Adm-Adr: news-answers-request@mit.edu.example Newsgroup-Type: Announce Date-Create: 19950725182040 Name: humanities.classics [...] -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.0.7 (IRIX64) iD8DBQE9Zj/Wn13IYldLZg8RAhWiAJ4y7o+3FzBpRjYJj2HWwXyG2g8FoQCfeEsH rRynPhhjveiY/XBkkrrZFho= =muK4 -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- . <-- GETP 0 0 19990909101000 de --> 213 You are up-to-date . <-- GETP foo --> 510 Syntax error Missing parameters . <-- GETP guest test 0 de --> 430 You have no permission to retrieve the data . 6.3.3.11. GETA Description The GETA command is used for server-server communication; it is used to collect authoritative data and will request packages that the server is authoritative for. A package is the authoritative data either for a newsgroup or a hierarchy. Each package has a "timestamp" attached to mark the revision of the package. This timestamp is set by the server to the date of the last modification of the package data in UTC format. A timestamp of "0" indicates that the package MUST be retrieved. If the retrieving client has a recent package (i.e., no modification on the authoritative server), the server sends only a 215 response. The format of the data is the same as that for the commands "HIER" and "LIST". geta-cmd = "GETA" WSP username WSP password WSP timestamp WSP name CRLF Possible answers 215: The client already has the current data 430: Permission denied 411: No hierarchy with that name 510: Syntax error 615: Regular answer with all requested data geta-answer = "615" [answertext] CRLF pgp-ascii-armor-start ; this is according to [RFC2440] *(getadata CRLF) pgp-ascii-armor-end ; this is according to [RFC2440] "." CRLF geta-answer =/ "215" [answertext] CRLF text CRLF "." CRLF geta-answer =/ "430" [answertext] CRLF text CRLF "." CRLF geta-answer =/ "411" [answertext] CRLF text CRLF "." CRLF geta-answer =/ "510" [answertext] CRLF text CRLF "." CRLF getadata = "Name:" WSP text CRLF "Status:" WSP text CRLF "Serial:" WSP timestamp CRLF *(header ":" WSP text CRLF) [("Ctl-PGP-Key:" CRLF PGP-answer/ "Mod-PGP-Key:" CRLF PGP-answer)] Example <-- GETA 0 0 0 humanities --> 615 data follow
EID 5827 (Verified) is as follows:

Section: 6.3.3.11

Original Text:

   <-- GETA 0 0 0 humanities
   --> 613 data follow

Corrected Text:

   <-- GETA 0 0 0 humanities
   --> 615 data follow
Notes:
Section 10 and also geta-answer in Section 6.3.3.11 indicates a 615 response code for GETA.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 Name: humanities Status: Complete Serial: 20020821094529 Description: Branches of learning that investigate human constructs and concerns as opposed to natural processes. Netiquette: ftp://rtfm.mit.edu.example/pub/usenet /news.announce.newusers /A_Primer_on_How_to_Work_With_the_Usenet_Community Rules: http://www.uvv.org.example/docs/howto.txt Ctl-Send-Adr: group-admin@isc.org.example Ctl-Newsgroup: news.announce.newgroup Language: EN Charset: US-ASCII Encoding: text/plain Newsgroup-Type: Discussion Hier-Type: Global Comp-Length: 14 Date-Create: 19950417143009 Name: humanities.answers Status: Moderated Serial: 20020821094533 Description: Repository for periodic USENET articles. (Moderated) Mod-Sub-Adr: news-answers@mit.edu.example Mod-Adm-Adr: news-answers-request@mit.edu.example Newsgroup-Type: Announce Date-Create: 19950725182040 Name: humanities.classics [...] -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1.0.7 (IRIX64) iD8DBQE9Zj/Wn13IYldLZg8RAhWiAJ4y7o+3FzBpRjYJj2HWwXyG2g8FoQCfeEsH rRynPhhjveiY/XBkkrrZFho= =muK4 -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- . 6.3.3.12. Unknown Commands and Syntax Errors If a command is recognized as unknown, a 519 return code (unknown command) is given. If an error occurs after the command string (e.g., a missing parameter), a 510 return code (Syntax error: Missing parameter) is given. 6.3.4. Data Headers The following paragraphs describe key words and key terms that support retrieval and storing of information. Every header has a unique English name. The content of a header is inheritable within a hierarchy, as long as the header is marked as inheritable. The content is the default value for all downstream newsgroups and sub-hierarchies. For example, in the hierarchy "de", the language header has the value "DE" (German); therefore, this value is "DE" for all newsgroups in this hierarchy, except for those that explicitly define a language code of their own. Hierarchies and newsgroups must have at least values for the headers "Name" and "Status". Unknown hierarchies or groups get the status "Unknown". The header used in the NAS protocol are not case sensitive. A header may be uppercase, lowercase, or any mixture of upper- and lowercase. It is recommended that the first letter of the header and the first letter after a dash be uppercase and that all other characters be lowercase. Name Header: Name Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: yes Inheritable: no Repeatable: no Description: Name of a hierarchy. Comment: Start of a new data block. Example: Name: comp Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: yes Repeatable: no Description: Name of a newsgroup Comment: Start of a new data block. Example: Name: de.admin.news.announce Status Header: Status Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: yes Inheritable: no Repeatable: no Description: Status of a hierarchy. Comment: For a detailed description, see Section 6.4. Example: Status: Hierarchy-Complete Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: yes Repeatable: no Description: Status of a newsgroup. Comment: For a detailed description, see Section 6.4. Example: Status: Group-Moderated Serial Header: Serial Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: no Repeatable: no Description: Timestamp for hierarchy data. Comment: For a detailed description, see Section 6.3.3.10. Example: Serial: 20020821102413 Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Inheritable: no Repeatable: no Description: Timestamp for newsgroup data. Comment: For a detailed description, see Section 6.3.3.10. Example: Serial: 20020821102413
EID 5831 (Verified) is as follows:

Section: 6.3.4

Original Text:

   Serial

   Header:      Serial

   Used for:    hierarchy
   Mandatory:   no
   Inheritable: no
   Repeatable:  no
   Description: Timestamp for hierarchy data.
   Comment:     For a detailed description, see Section 6.4.
   Example:     Serial: 20020821102413

   Used for:    newsgroup
   Mandatory:   no
   Inheritable: no
   Repeatable:  no
   Description: Timestamp for newsgroup data.
   Comment:     For a detailed description, see Section 6.4.
   Example:     Serial: 20020821102413

Corrected Text:

   Serial

   Header:      Serial

   Used for:    hierarchy
   Mandatory:   no
   Inheritable: no
   Repeatable:  no
   Description: Timestamp for hierarchy data.
   Comment:     For a detailed description, see Section 6.3.3.10.
   Example:     Serial: 20020821102413

   Used for:    newsgroup
   Mandatory:   no
   Inheritable: no
   Repeatable:  no
   Description: Timestamp for newsgroup data.
   Comment:     For a detailed description, see Section 6.3.3.10.
   Example:     Serial: 20020821102413
Notes:
Its use as a timestamp is described in Section 6.3.3.10, for both hierarchies and newsgroups.
Group for followup Header: Followup Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: no Description: Name of the newsgroup that will take the followup postings of a moderated group. Comment: The value can be used as default value for the "Followup-To:" header on postings to a moderated group. This value is only useful on groups that are moderated (Status Group-Moderated) and have a dedicated discussion group. Example: Followup: bln.announce.fub.zedat.d (for the moderated group bln.announce.fub.zedat) Short description Header: Description Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: no Repeatable: no Description: Short description of a hierarchy. Example: Description: Angelegenheiten, die den Grossraum Berlin betreffen (for the hierarchy bln) Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: no Description: Short description of a newsgroup. Comment: This information is often presented to the news reader upon selection of the newsgroup, and it should be a brief but meaningful description of the topic. Example: Description: Technisches zur Newssoftware (for de.admin.news.software) Charter-URL Header: Charter Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: no Repeatable: yes Description: URL that points to the charter of a hierarchy. Example: Charter: ftp://ftp.fu-berlin.de.example/doc/news/bln/bln (for the hierarchy bln) Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: yes Description: URL that points to the charter of a newsgroup. Comment: This information should be presented to the news reader upon selection of the newsgroup. Example: Charter: ftp://ftp.fu-berlin.de.example/doc/news/bln /bln.markt.arbeit Netiquette-URL Header: Netiquette Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: yes Description: URL that points to the netiquette of a hierarchy. Comment: Since the netiquettes are often valid for a complete hierarchy, this is inheritable. Example: Netiquette: http://www.kirchwitz.de.example/~amk/dni/netiquette Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: yes Description: URL for Netiquette. Comment: If a group has some special rules, this is the pointer to these rules. Example: Netiquette: http://go.to.example/bln.markt (for bln.markt) Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) Header: FAQ Used for: Newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: yes Description: URL for the FAQ of a newsgroup. Example: FAQ: http://www.dard.de.example/ Administration rules Header: Rules Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: yes Description: URL pointing to a document that describes the rules for creating, deleting, or renaming newsgroups in this hierarchy. Comment: Normally inherited from the toplevel hierarchy. Example: Rules: http://www.kirchwitz.de.example/~amk/dai /einrichtung Control Email Header: Ctl-Send-Adr Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: yes Description: Email address of the sender of control messages. Comment: Multiple addresses are valid. Example: Ctl-Send-Adr: group-admin@isc.org.example Control newsgroup Header: Ctl-Newsgroup Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: yes Description: Name of the newsgroup that will get the postings for checkgroups, rmgroup, and newsgroup control messages. Example: Ctl-Newsgroup: de.admin.news.groups Moderators Header: Mod-Wildcard Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: no Description: Moderator wildcard for this hierarchy. Comment: This information can be used for the configuration of the news software, for example, to configure the moderators file in INN. Example: Mod-Wildcard: %s@moderators.dana.de.example (for the hierarchy de) Submission address Header: Mod-Sub-Adr Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: yes Description: Email address for submissions to the newsgroup. Comment: If there is no "Mod-Sub-Adr" for a moderated newsgroup, "Mod-Wildcard" of the hierarchy is used. This is useful only for moderated groups (Status Group-Moderated). Example: Mod-Sub-Adr: news-answers@mit.edu.example (for the newsgroup news.answers) Moderator's address (email) Header: Mod-Adm-Adr Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: yes Description: Email address of the moderator of the newsgroup. Comment: If there is no code "Mod-Adm-Adr" for a moderated newsgroup, "Mod-Wildcard" of the hierarchy is used. This is useful only for moderated groups (Status Group-Moderated). Example: Mod-Adm-Adr: news-answers-request@mit.edu.example (for the newsgroup news.answers) Info-URL Header: Mod-Group-Info Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: yes Description: URL that points to a document where the moderator presents information about the newsgroup and the submission of articles. Example: Mod-Group-Info: http://www.example.org/cola-submit.html (for comp.os.linux.announce) Language Header: Language Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: yes Description: The language that will normally be used in postings. Comment: The notation is according to the "Content-Language" field of [RFC2616]. The languages not preferred are enclosed in parentheses. Example: Language: DE (for the hierarchy de) Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: yes Description: The language that will normally be used in postings. Comment: The notation is according to the "Content-Language" field of [RFC2616]. The languages not preferred are enclosed in parentheses. Example: Language: TR Language: DE Language: (EN) (for the newsgroup bln.kultur.tuerkisch) Charset Header: Charset Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: yes Description: Charset that will normally be used in postings in this hierarchy. Comment: The complete set of charset names is defined by [RFC2277] and the IANA Character Set registry [IANA-CS]. The charsets that are not the preferred charsets are enclosed in parentheses. Example: Charset: ISO-8859-1 (for the hierarchy de) Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: yes Description: Charset that will normally be used in postings in this group. Comment: The complete set of charset names is defined by [RFC2277] and the IANA Character Set registry [IANA-CS]. The charsets that are not the preferred charsets are enclosed in parentheses. Example: Charset: ISO-8859-9 Charset: ISO-8859-1 (for the newsgroup bln.kultur.tuerkisch) Encoding Header: Encoding Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: yes Description: Encoding for this hierarchy according to MIME [RFC2045]. Comment: This is the media type used in this hierarchy; a list of registered media types can be found at [IANA-MT]. The encodings not preferred are enclosed in parentheses. Example: Encoding text/plain Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: yes Description: Encoding for this newsgroup according to MIME [RFC2045]. Comment This is the media type used in this newsgroup; a list of registered media types can be found at [IANA-MT]. The encodings not preferred are enclosed in parentheses. Example: Encoding: text/plain Type of newsgroup Header: Newsgroup-Type Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: yes Description: Default newsgroup type in this hierarchy. Comment: This header has no concrete meaning for a hierarchy but is used for the inheritance to newsgroups in the hierarchy. Specification of the types can be found in Section 6.5. Example: Newsgroup-Type: Discussion (for the hierarchy de) Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: yes Description: Type of newsgroup. Comment: Specification of the types can be found in Section 6.5. Example: Newsgroup-Type: Announce (for de.admin.news.announce) Type of hierarchy Header: Hier-Type Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: yes Description: Type of hierarchy. Comment: Specification of the types can be found in Section 6.6. Example: Hier-Type: Regional (for hierarchy bln) Regional or Organizational Area Header: Area Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: yes Description: Description of the geographical region or organization of this hierarchy. Comment: This code is useful when the hierarchy type (Hier-Type) is "Regional" or "Organization". Example: Area: Grossraum Berlin (for the hierarchy bln) Name length of group names Header: Name-Length Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: no Description: Maximum length of a newsgroup name. Example: Name-Length: 72 (for the hierarchy bln) Component length of group names Header: Comp-Length Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: no Description: Maximum length of a single component in the newsgroup name. Example: Comp-Length: 14 (for the hierarchy de) Article length Header: Article-Length Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: no Description: Maximum length of an article in bytes. Comment: This header has no concrete meaning for a hierarchy but is used for the inheritance to newsgroups in the hierarchy. Example: Article-Length: 50000 Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: no Description: Maximum length of an article in bytes. Example: Article-Length: 50000 Date of creation Header: Date-Create Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: no Description: Creation date of a hierarchy; can even be in the future. Comment: The format is the same as in the DATE command. Example: Date-Create: 19970330101514 Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: no Description: Creation date of a newsgroup; can even be in the future. Comment: The format is the same as in the DATE command. Example: Date-Create: 19970330101514 Date of removal Header: Date-Delete Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: no Description: Date of removal of a hierarchy; can even be in the future. Comment: The format is the same as in the DATE command. Example: Date-Delete: 19970330101514 Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: no Description: Date of removal of a newsgroup; can even be in the future. Comment: The format is the same as in the DATE command. Example: Date-Delete: 19970330101514 Successor Header: Replacement Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: no Repeatable: yes Description: Name of the hierarchy that replaced a removed hierarchy if status is "Hierarchy-Obsolete" or will replace a hierarchy if the date of removal is in the future. Example: Replacement: de (for the hierarchy sub) Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: yes Description: Name of the newsgroup or newsgroups that will replace a removed newsgroup if status is "Group-Removed" or will replace the newsgroup if the date of removal is in the future. Example: Replacement: bln.markt.arbeit (for bln.jobs) Source Header: Source Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: no Description: Pointer to an organization or person responsible for this hierarchy. SHOULD be a URL or an email address. Example: Source: http://www.dana.de.example/mod/ (for the hierarchy de) E: This is for tracking the maintainer of a hierarchy. Control PGP key Header: Ctl-PGP-Key Used for: hierarchy Mandatory: no Inheritable: yes Repeatable: yes Description: PGP key (with additional information: key owner, key-id, etc.) of the sender of control messages in this hierarchy. Comment: The exact format is described in Section 6.7. Example: Ctl-PGP-Key: U de.admin.news.announce B 1024 I D3033C99 L http://www.dana.de.example/mod/pgp/dana.asc L ftp://ftp.isc.org.example/pub/pgpcontrol/PGPKEYS.gz F 5B B0 52 88 BF 55 19 4F 66 7D C2 AE 16 26 28 25 V 2.6.3ia K------BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- K-Version: 2.6.3ia K- K-mQCNEALZ+Xfm/WDCEMXM48gK1PlKG6TkV3SLbXt4CnzpGM0tOMa K-HjlHqM1wEGUHD5hw/BL/heR5Tq+C5IEyXQQmYwkrgeVFMOz/rAQ [...] K-SDw+iQgAAtN6zrYOhHFBp+ K-VpvRovMz+lSOy9Zcsbs+5t8Pj9ZVAQyfxBkqD5A= K-=Xwgc K -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- Moderator's PGP key Header: Mod-PGP-Key Used for: newsgroup Mandatory: no Repeatable: yes Description: Public PGP key (with additional information: key owner, key-id, etc.) of this newsgroup's moderator. Comment: The exact format is described in Section 6.7 Example: See Section 6.7. 6.4. Status Indicators The status indicator uniquely determines the status of a hierarchy or newsgroup. The indicator is case insensitive. Indicator Type Description ----------- --------- ------------------------------------------- Complete hierarchy Authorized, complete known hierarchy Incomplete hierarchy Not completely known hierarchy (like free.*) Obsolete hierarchy Obsolete hierarchy; should contain only newsgroups with status "Removed" Unknown hierarchy No information available; unknown hierarchy Unmoderated newsgroup Posting allowed; unmoderated Readonly newsgroup Posting not allowed Moderated newsgroup Moderated group; articles must be sent to the moderator Removed newsgroup Deleted or renamed newsgroup; no posting or transport Unknown newsgroup Unknown group; no information available ----------- --------- ------------------------------------------- 6.5. Newsgroup Types A Newsgroup Type is a comprehensive overview about some characteristics of a newsgroup, being a test group, a binary group, or some other kind. The Newsgroup Type is case insensitive. Type Meaning ----------- ------------------------------------------------------ Discussion Discussion (text postings) Binary (Encoded) binary postings Sources Source postings (e.g., comp.unix.sources) Announce Announcements, press releases, RfD/CfV Test Test postings, sometimes reflectors (e.g., de.test) Robots Automatic postings (like the former comp.mail.maps) Experiment Experimental, other ----------- ------------------------------------------------------ 6.6. Hierarchy Types To describe a hierarchy, the following Hierarchy Types are used. These Types are used to mark some properties of a news hierarchy. They are case insensitive. Type Meaning -------------- --------------------------------------------------- Global International, global hierarchy (e.g., the hierarchies comp, de, rec) Regional Regional hierarchy (e.g., the hierarchies ba, bln, tor) Alt Alternative hierarchy, simpler rules for creating a group, no formal structure (e.g., the hierarchy alt) Non-commercial Only for personal use; commercial use is prohibited (e.g., the hierarchy de) Commercial Commercial use permitted (e.g., the hierarchy biz) Organization Hierarchy bound to an organization (e.g., the hierarchy gnu) -------------- --------------------------------------------------- 6.7. PGP Keys PGP keys for Ctrl-PGP-Key and Mod-PGP-Key are transmitted in the following structure: PGP-answer = "V" SP Version CRLF "U" SP User-ID CRLF "B" SP Bits CRLF "I" SP Key-ID CRLF "F" SP Finger CRLF *("L" SP Location CRLF) *("K-" Keyblock CRLF) "K" SP Keyblock CRLF Version = text User-ID = text Bits = text Key-ID = text Finger = text Location = text Keyblock = text Key Name Mandatory Description --- --------- --------- -------------------------------------- K Keyblock yes Public key block in ASCII armor format [RFC2440] V Version yes PGP-Version U User-ID no Key user id B Bits no Number of bits I Key-ID no Key id, without leading "0x" F Finger no Fingerprint L Location no URL that points to the public key --- --------- --------- -------------------------------------- A hyphen following the code indicates that the block is continued on the next line. In the last message row, there MUST be white space after the code; this is also true for a single line code. Example <-- HIER de --> 611 Data coming Name: de Status: Hierarchy [...] Ctl-PGP-Key: U de.admin.news.announce B 1024 I D3033C99 L http://www.dana.de.example/mod/pgp/dana.asc L ftp://ftp.fu-berlin.de.example/unix/news/pgpcontrol/PGPKEYS.gz F 5B B0 52 88 BF 55 19 4F 66 7D C2 AE 16 26 28 25 V 2.6.3ia K------BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- K-Version: 2.6.3ia K- K-mQCNAzGeB/YAAAEEALZ+Xfm/WDCEMXM48gK1PlKG6TkV3SLbXt4CnzpGMtOM K-HjlHaU6Xco5ijAuqM1wEGUHD5hw/BL/heR5Tq+C5IEyXQQmYwkrgeVFMO/rA [...] K-SDw+Id0JPFO9AWOiQgAAtN6zrYOhHFBp+68h9k674Yg9IHqj3BWdRjJF6PKo K-VpvRovMz+lSOy9Zcsbs+5t8Pj9ZVAQyfxBkqD5A= K-=Xwgc K -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- [...] . 7. Specification of the NAS Protocol (UDP) UDP is intended for reading programs (news readers); it is not in the scope of this document. The use of UDP for NAS will be described in a separate paper. 8. IANA Considerations The IANA has registered the application/nasdata media type as defined by the following information: Media type name: application Media subtype name: nasdata Required parameters: none Optional parameters: level The NAS protocol level number for the enclosed NAS data package. If not present, the protocol level defaults to 1. Encoding scheme: NAS data is plain text; no special encodings are needed. Security considerations: see below 9. Security Considerations Security issues are only addressed in respect to server-server communication in this protocol level. Username and password combinations in the GETA and GETP commands can be used to make sure that connections are only accepted from authorized clients. PGP keys according to [RFC2440] are used to sign NAS data in server-server communication in order to validate that the data is authentic and has not been tampered with. Every server does have the possibility (in both server-server and server-client communication) to deny some commands or the whole connection according to the client's IP number. No mechanisms are defined in the current protocol level to allow a client to validate that it is talking to a legitimate server or that the data it receives is authentic. A stronger authentication scheme will be provided in a higher protocol level. 10. Response Codes (Overview) Code Description ---- -------------------------------------------------------------- 100 Command overview, Information, command description (HELP) 101 Information about connection, client and server (INFO) 200 Greeting message (Connection Setup) 201 Termination of the connection (QUIT) 202 Returns current protocol level (VERS) 213 Valid data at the client side (GETP) 215 The client already has the current data (GETA) 300 Time in UTC (DATE) 302 Answer to a successful request (VERS) 400 Indicates that the server is not giving any information (INFO) 401 Permission denied (LIST, LSTR, HIER, DATA) 402 Requested level too high; falling back to lower level (VERS) 404 Server currently out of service (Connection Setup) 410 Indicates that the server is not giving any information (HELP) 411 No hierarchy with that name (GETP, GETA) 430 Permission denied (GETP, GETA) 434 Client has no permission to talk to server (Connection Setup) 510 Syntax error 511 Internal error (TIME) 513 Line too long 519 Unknown command 610 Regular answer with all requested data (LIST, LSTR) 611 Regular answer with all requested data (HIER) 612 Regular answer with all requested data (DATA) 613 hierarchy data (GETP) 615 Regular answer with all requested data (GETA) ---- -------------------------------------------------------------- 11. Data Headers for DATA and HIER Commands (Overview) Header Mandatory Use Multiple Description ------------- --------- --- -------- --------------------- Name yes H/N no Name of a hierarchy or newsgroup (Start of a new data block) Status yes H/N no Status of hierarchy or newsgroup Serial no H/N no Revision of hierarchy /newsgroup data Followup no N no Group for followup Description no H/N no Short description of a hierarchy/newsgroup Charter no H/N yes Charter-URL Netiquette no H/N yes Netiquette-URL FAQ no N yes FAQ-URL Rules no H yes Administration rules URL Ctl-Send-Adr no H yes Control email Ctl-Newsgroup no H yes Control newsgroup Mod-Wildcard no H no Moderator wildcard Mod-Sub-Adr no N yes Submission address
EID 5834 (Verified) is as follows:

Section: 11

Original Text:

    Mod-Sub-Adr      no           N    no         Submission address

Corrected Text:

    Mod-Sub-Adr      no           N    yes        Submission address
Notes:
This header is repeatable, as stated in its definition in Section 6.3.4.
A newsgroup may have several e-mails to be reached.
Mod-Adm-Adr no N yes Moderator's address (email) Mod-Group-Info no N yes Info-URL Language no H/N yes Language Charset no H/N yes Charset Encoding no H/N yes Encoding Newsgroup-Type no H/N yes Type of newsgroup Hier-Type no H yes Type of hierarchy Area no H yes Regional or organizational area Name-Length no H no Total length of group names Comp-Length no H no Component length of group names Article-Length no H/N no Article length
EID 5836 (Verified) is as follows:

Section: 11

Original Text:

    Article-Length   no           H    no         Article length

Corrected Text:

    Article-Length   no          H/N    no        Article length
Notes:
As stated in the definition of Article-Length in Section 6.3.4, it also applies to newsgroups.
Date-Create no H/N no Date of creation Date-Delete no H/N no Date of removal Replacement no H/N yes Successor Source no H yes Source of data Ctl-PGP-Key no H yes Control PGP key Mod-PGP-Key no N yes Moderator's PGP key ------------- --------- --- -------- --------------------- N: Newsgroup, H: Hierarchy 12. References 12.1. Normative References [IANA-CS] IANA: Character Sets, <http://www.iana.org/assignments/character-sets>. [RFC2045] Freed, N. and N. Borenstein, "Multipurpose Internet Mail Extensions (MIME) Part One: Format of Internet Message Bodies", RFC 2045, November 1996. [RFC2119] Bradner, S., "Key words for use in RFCs to Indicate Requirement Levels", BCP 14, RFC 2119, March 1997. [RFC2277] Alvestrand, H., "IETF Policy on Character Sets and Languages", BCP 18, RFC 2277, January 1998. [RFC2440] Callas, J., Donnerhacke, L., Finney, H., and R. Thayer, "OpenPGP Message Format", RFC 2440, November 1998. [RFC2616] Fielding, R., Gettys, J., Mogul, J., Frystyk, H., Masinter, L., Leach, P., and T. Berners-Lee, "Hypertext Transfer Protocol -- HTTP/1.1", RFC 2616, June 1999. [RFC4234] Crocker, D. and P. Overell, "Augmented BNF for Syntax Specifications: ABNF", RFC 4234, October 2005. 12.2. Informative References [IANA-MT] IANA: Media Types, <http://www.iana.org/assignments/>. [IANA-PN] IANA: Assigned Port Numbers, <http://www.iana.org/assignments/port-numbers>. [RFC1305] Mills, D., "Network Time Protocol", RFC 1305, University of Delaware, March 1992. [SON1036] H. Spencer, "News Article Format and Transmission", A Draft for an RFC 1036 Successor, <ftp://zoo.toronto.edu/pub/news.txt.Z>. [USEFOR] USEFOR Working Group, "News Article Format", Work in Progress. Acknowledgement This work has been supported by the German Academic Network Organization (DFN-Verein) with funds from the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (Bundesministerium fuer Bildung und Forschung). Authors' Addresses Philipp Grau Vera Heinau Heiko Schlichting Robert Schuettler Freie Universitaet Berlin ZEDAT Fabeckstr. 32 14195 Berlin Germany Phone: +49 30 838-74707 Fax: +49 30 838-56721 EMail: nas@fu-berlin.de URL: http://nas.fu-berlin.de/ Full Copyright Statement Copyright (C) The Internet Society (2006). This document is subject to the rights, licenses and restrictions contained in BCP 78 and at www.rfc-editor.org/copyright.html, and except as set forth therein, the authors retain all their rights. This document and the information contained herein are provided on an "AS IS" basis and THE CONTRIBUTOR, THE ORGANIZATION HE/SHE REPRESENTS OR IS SPONSORED BY (IF ANY), THE INTERNET SOCIETY AND THE INTERNET ENGINEERING TASK FORCE DISCLAIM ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO ANY WARRANTY THAT THE USE OF THE INFORMATION HEREIN WILL NOT INFRINGE ANY RIGHTS OR ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. Intellectual Property The IETF takes no position regarding the validity or scope of any Intellectual Property Rights or other rights that might be claimed to pertain to the implementation or use of the technology described in this document or the extent to which any license under such rights might or might not be available; nor does it represent that it has made any independent effort to identify any such rights. Information on the procedures with respect to rights in RFC documents can be found in BCP 78 and BCP 79. Copies of IPR disclosures made to the IETF Secretariat and any assurances of licenses to be made available, or the result of an attempt made to obtain a general license or permission for the use of such proprietary rights by implementers or users of this specification can be obtained from the IETF on-line IPR repository at http://www.ietf.org/ipr. The IETF invites any interested party to bring to its attention any copyrights, patents or patent applications, or other proprietary rights that may cover technology that may be required to implement this standard. Please address the information to the IETF at ietf-ipr@ietf.org. Acknowledgement Funding for the RFC Editor function is provided by the IETF Administrative Support Activity (IASA).